Family Secrets

Coben brings Win, Windsor Horne Lockwood III, out of mothballs and onto center stage in this self-titled adventure. Even though Coben’s books don’t lend themselves to great discussions at book club, we all love them.  And it’s good to read something fun and enjoyable. Besides he’s a Jersey boy.

How a family can lie to cover its secrets?  Win gets involved in a case with connections back to his family. He peels back the layers of lies and coverups and discovers a tragic truth. A painting belonging to Win’s family had been recovered at a home where a man was killed. Win has no idea who the man is or how he got that painting. Then the dead man turns out to be a member of a radical left group responsible for the killing of seven people decades earlier. Already intrigued, he becomes obsessed when his favorite cousin’s kidnapping around the same time is connected.

I prefer Win as Myron Bolitar’s sidekick. The two complement each other to perfection. Myron’s grounded character gives Win some great comic moments and curbs his egomania to somewhat acceptable levels. Win in a whole novel is a lot to take.

Our book club talked about the decisions made by family members and how they can affect several generations – the sins of the father, so to speak. We also talked about how lies grow and take on a life of their own.  Fun read but not great discussion.

Rating: 7.5

Photo: Vermeer’s The Milkmaid, Rijksmuseum

When family disintegrates

The Vanishing Half by Brit Bennett

As the weather chilled and the leaves started to turn color, so did our taste in books.  We chose The Vanishing Half by Brit Bennett.

What makes a family? Having dinner every Sunday at mom’s house? Genetics? What bond ties a family together? These were the conversations we had at book club about this superb book.

Mallard, Louisiana was home to light-skinned blacks who didn’t marry “dark.”  The Vignes’ twins, Desiree and Stella, were raised that way. One traumatic night their father was ripped out of their home by a gang of white men for no reason and lynched. This atrocious event scared the twins in different ways and at sixteen they ran away to New Orleans. But after only one year Stella left, disappeared without one word to her twin sister. The book then splits following each twin on their life course.

This book plunges beyond the surface of its characters down to their souls, laying bare their shattered lives.

We talked about how an event in our past affects the present.  How it impacts our daily decisions. We were intrigued by their story and wanted to find out more about the twins. Did they find happiness? Do they reunite?

Great book for discussion, which, of course, is always what book club is all about.

Rating: 8.5

Photo by Kool C on Unsplash